ISLAMABAD. There is no friendship like the all-weather one and I say so as a man who has watched our friend produce a great deal of weather lately. The Fifth Plenum closed on 29 October. In Islamabad we have been admiring it ever since, much as one admires a neighbour who has decided to repaint the house by removing the tenants.
The Guest List
Reuters reported on 29 October that the Communist Party confirmed the expulsion of 33 officials, among them former Politburo members Ma Xingrui and Zhang Youxia, former diplomat Liu Jianchao and former industry minister Jin Zhuanglong. Only 279 of the 376 members and alternates originally named in 2022 attended, a rate of about 74 per cent and Reuters said, the highest absence rate of the post-Mao era. SCMP counted 16 of the 33 as senior military officers. The Jamestown Foundation, in a briefing, said just five of the 44 military members of the Central Committee formally attended, or 11 per cent.
Reuters also noted that the plenum unexpectedly raised General Zhang Shengmin to the Politburo. Jamestown observed that he oversaw the military purge as discipline chief and that no new members were added to the Central Military Commission.
The Empty Chairs
Taiwanese experts at a Taipei seminar, reported by the Taipei Times on 1 November, said the seven-member commission of 2022 is down to Xi Jinping and Zhang Shengmin. That leaves five seats vacant and two occupied, or 29 per cent of the original body. One speaker, Chen Shih-min, said the PLA’s table of organisation calls for more than 40 full generals and admirals and only six remain, at most 15 per cent. Another, Chieh Chung, counted 96 Central Committee members, 26 per cent, departed under a cloud and said it would force a re-examination of defence procurement plans. A third, Ma Chen-kun, said the PLA would be absorbed in recovery for up to two years.
These speakers argue that the purge lowers the risk of a planned war while raising the risk of an accident and their seminar was organised by a Taiwan think tank, so the reader may weigh the flavour. Beijing’s own phrase is that the officials violated discipline and law; the campaign, it insists, is about discipline.
Lean, Mean and Double Sided
The force is also economising. A South China Monitoring Post (SCMP) report on the PLA’s thrift campaign, published on 1 November, say units are promoting double-sided printing, recycling parts, salvaging screws and distributing second-hand briefcases. SCMP separately reported on 6 November that the new theatre commanders could be identified from insignia and seating arrangements at a Beijing conclave. In the all-weather tradition we, too, announce our commanders by who sits where, though in our case the seating chart is permanent.
Meanwhile Zhang Shengmin received Russian Defence Minister Andrey Belousov in Beijing on 3 November, SCMP reported, pledging deeper military cooperation. The command may be thin, but it is evidently still available for lunch.
Our Side of the Table
Karakoram 2026, the first China-Pakistan joint army training, opened on 14 October in Korla, Xinjiang, Chinese state media said, with counter-terrorism work in high terrain and drone training; Pakistani troops observed some Chinese weapons and equipment. Global Times pointed to an all-Chinese equipment lineup. A Chinese analyst told it the drill showed growing mutual military trust. I take that trust to be mutual.
Then, on 7 November, the China Manned Space Agency announced that a Pakistani payload specialist will fly on Shenzhou-24, the first foreigner to visit China’s station, Al Jazeera and AFP reported. The astronaut is unnamed, no date has been given beyond the end of the year, and Al Jazeera found no Pakistani government statement. On the announced calendar, a Pakistani will reach orbit well before the Commission’s five empty chairs are refilled; the next Party Congress is set for the second half of 2027. We have a seat in space and the host has vacancies on earth.
Our own establishment prefers the opposite approach to personnel: nobody is expelled, rank is added. I mention this only so that no reader mistakes the Chinese method for a model.
The Pakistani astronaut will go up in one Chinese spacecraft and come down in another. In the all-weather friendship, as in orbit, it is wise to ask who holds the return ticket.





