The News Central

A Paper Anniversary: One Year of the 27th Amendment

ISLAMABAD. Tomorrow is 13 November 2026 and the 27th Amendment turns one. President Zardari signed it on 13 November last year, a day after the National Assembly ratified it with a two-thirds majority, according to Chatham House. Traditionally the first anniversary is paper, which suits an amendment that has done so much for the use of paper. I have wrapped nothing yet. I am still looking for the right size of box.

Three days

The Senate passed the bill on Monday, 10 November, as the Associated Press reported. The President signed it on Thursday. That is three days from one chamber's vote to a signature. Nukta counted 48 articles in the draft that it targeted for change, which works out at sixteen articles a day (my arithmetic and a generous one, since it ignores the committee work Gulf News describes beforehand). Some constitutions get debated. This one got a conveyor belt and I admire the throughput.

What the government said

The case for it deserves its own paragraph. Law Minister Azam Nazeer Tarar told lawmakers that a separate Federal Constitutional Court would let the Supreme Court concentrate on its appellate work and speed up civil and criminal cases. The Express Tribune gave the stated purpose as to “improve governance, defence and the delivery of justice system.” The Pakistan Ex-Servicemen Society welcomed the army reforms in the package, Dawn reported at the time. If the point was to move cases along, one year in, there ought to be a number to show for it. I looked for a published count of the backlog before and after and did not find one in the time I had. If the court has such a figure I would be glad to print it, with credit.

What the critics said

The International Commission of Jurists called the amendment a “flagrant attack on the independence of the judiciary” on the day it passed. Amnesty International raised concerns in a January briefing about how the court's judges are appointed and Chatham House argued that the changes moved Pakistan a step toward authoritarian rule. The government's answer, to the extent it has given one, is the paragraph above. I will leave the two sides to meet. They have had a year and are not yet speaking.

The part about the Field Marshal

The amendment made the Chief of Army Staff the Chief of Defence Forces, a post that replaced the old Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee and it let the army chief rise to the rank of Field Marshal. Chatham House adds that it grants lifetime immunity from prosecution to a five-star officer, a rank held only by Asim Munir. WION's headline at the time said the same thing in blunter words. Supporters would put it differently, I am sure and I invite them to.

I find one provision a small delight. Under the same package, the Express Tribune reports, a stay order in a revenue or tax case now lapses automatically if the case is undecided after one year, where it used to be six months. So, a company's interim relief has a clock of twelve months. The immunity, on Chatham House's reading, has a clock of the officer's life. The ratio is a matter of taste.

A word for the court

The Federal Constitutional Court's first chief justice is Justice Aminuddin Khan, who earlier led the constitutional bench set up under the 26th Amendment. Its chief justice serves a fixed three-year term and its judges retire at 68. The Supreme Court remains the final appeal in ordinary civil and criminal matters. I note all this because last year I could not decide whether the new court was a ministry or a bench and I am pleased to report that after twelve months I can say I still do not know. That is the only honest answer available to a person who has not seen the docket.

There is, to repeat, a defensible account in which one court for constitutional questions and one for ordinary appeals is simply tidier. Many democracies have a constitutional court. The disagreement here is about who appoints it and who answers to it and a year is a short time to settle that.

GIFT RECEIPT  
Item: one amendment, first anniversary.  
Exchanges: not accepted.  
Refunds: see Article 175B and following.