The News Central

The Arithmetic of Victory

Editor's Note: Our fact-checking desk asked that this column come with receipts. They are attached at the end. That is more than the original statements managed.

The Arithmetic of Victory

Editor's Note: Our fact-checking desk asked that this column come with receipts. They are attached at the end. That is more than the original statements managed.

ISLAMABAD. A patriot should begin his Friday with good news and the military's media wing obliged. Seventy-four terrorists, I read, were sent to their reward by our forces. I put down my tea in admiration and then, because I am an old-fashioned man who still likes to add things up, I picked it up again.

The seventy-four is two numbers wearing one coat. Forty-three of them were killed in the past forty-eight hours, thirty-five at Mir Ali and eight in Orakzai. The other thirty-one were killed in Balochistan since 3 November, in what the statement calls the Kurram area of Quetta district. Ten days of work and two days of work, added together and presented as a single morning. I have no complaint. A nation that rounds so confidently will never be short of confidence. I will say only that Kurram is a district I had always filed under Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and that nobody at the press desk seems to have been asked about it.

What the statement did not say interests me more. It named no soldier killed, as reported by Dawn and ARY. It named no unit and no officer and it named no civilian. Our boys, it seems, go into the fiercest exchange of fire in the history of the grammatical sentence and emerge entirely undented. Only on 1 November, in Kharan, did the army admit to losing a sepoy, Hikmatullah and he is given a name precisely once.

The ledger we keep for ourselves

Do not mistake me. The army does count it’s dead when it must. On 31 July the Director General of ISPR told the press that this year's total stood at 819 martyred, made up of 303 soldiers, 194 personnel of other law enforcement agencies and 322 civilians. In the same breath he reported 40,348 operations and 2,084 terrorists killed, which he put at about ten a day. By my own arithmetic that is one confirmed kill for every nineteen operations and nearly four of our own dead every day of the year. The general public is invited to admire the first figure. The second is what the families are left with.

The generosity extends to the big days. After the three attacks in Balochistan in early July, the Director General held a press conference and gave the army's side honestly: eleven soldiers killed in the Bela-Winder convoy, nine policemen at Ziarat, thirty-eight security personnel in all. It is touching how the truth arrives the moment it can no longer be avoided.

It is also touching what happens when it can. On Thursday the Baloch Liberation Army said a suicide vehicle had destroyed the army camp at Kundab in Mastung and claimed eighteen dead. Local media, as reported by the Daily Pioneer, spoke of dozens. In everything I could find, the military had said nothing at all. The next morning came the seventy-four, from other places. Never let it be said that our press release schedule does not know how to change the subject.

The missing, found at last

My favourite statement of the year came in that same July briefing. The Director General remarked that figures for Baloch missing persons are quoted inconsistently, anywhere from ten thousand to twenty thousand and that many of the militants killed in operations turned out to be people previously reported missing. I take my hat off. Every grieving family waiting outside the Quetta Press Club, a camp that passed six thousand days a year ago this month, can now rest easy that their relative may well have been located. I saw no list of names. A patriot does not ask for lists.

The activist counts are of course unreliable and I say so as a matter of national duty. The Baloch Yakjehti Committee puts enforced disappearances in the first half of 2026 at 507 and Paank at 556 and neither number can be independently checked. What can be checked is the fate of the woman who asked the question loudest. Dr Mahrang Baloch is serving two life sentences, Amnesty International says, after a trial UN experts have called unfair. The Sindh High Court threw out the state's appeal against her one acquittal on 19 October. Even our prosecutors, it appears, can run out of patience with the evidence.

Rawalakot keeps two sets of books

Nowhere is the double-entry system more advanced than in Azad Kashmir. After the July clashes, AJK police said three people linked to the Awami Action Committee and four law enforcement personnel had died. The Committee said seven of its people had been killed, with the electricity cut and firing in the dark. On 5 November ThePrint reported seven dead and Daily Pakistan reported no toll. On Thursday, two girls were shot in Rawalakot. The police, in a statement carried by Radio Pakistan, said they were injured by firing from the banned group's armed men. The Committee and Kashmir Times, said one was killed by the security forces. Both versions arrived within hours. Neither came with a witness.

Even within the government the figures refuse to marry. AJK police say 26 of their personnel have died this year. The AJK information secretary says seven. One of these men is wrong by a factor of almost four and since both speak for the same administration, I have decided they are both right and that the dead have simply been counted on different days. The notification that banned the Committee was issued on 5 June, only months after the state signed an agreement with the same leaders. It has since been reinstating the cases it withdrew under that agreement. A consistent policy, if you squint.

Who commands the operation, I cannot tell you. The statements come from the police, the information secretary and a DIG's spokesman. A Sindh Rangers naik, Bostan Khan, died of his wounds on 8 November, which suggests that forces from Karachi are doing duty in Poonch. The chairman of the Overseas Pakistanis Foundation, whose letter-writing the Committee attributed to the Army Chief's blessing, denied that the Field Marshal had sent him, then said he was acting in his official capacity, then said it was personal. I have never seen so many hats on one head.

Why the numbers disagree

A cynic would say each ledger serves its keeper. The army counts kills because kills are its argument for the budget and for the next operation. The activists count the missing because the missing are theirs. The police count their dead when the Interior Ministry needs one more reason for a ban. I am not a cynic. I merely observe that PICSS recorded seventy-one attacks in Balochistan in October, down from 132 and then Mastung happened. The monitors say the province recorded 829 deaths between July and September, more than three times the previous quarter. It is difficult to tell a shrinking insurgency from a long exhale and I notice that nobody in uniform is trying.

There is a lesson here that even a loyal correspondent may state aloud. A force that cannot publish who it killed, who it lost and who is in command is not defeating anything. It is managing a story. The story is well managed and I have never doubted the quality of the management. It is the ground I worry about.

Closing note: The correspondent was asked to confirm that every figure above is accurate. He has confirmed that every figure above is official, which he is told is a different thing. The desk wishes to record that it did not choose the distinction.

Sources

-     ISPR, 74 killed, 13 Nov 2026: Dawn https://www.dawn.com/news/2044260/security-forces-kill-74-terrorists-during-ibos-in-khyber-pakhtunkhwa-balochistan-ispr ; ARY https://arynews.tv/74-khwarij-killed-in-security-operations-in-quetta-and-kp-ispr ; Daily Pakistan https://en.dailypakistan.com.pk/13-Nov-2026/pakistan-forces-kill-74-indian-sponsored-terrorists-in-kp-balochistan-ibos ; Minute Mirror https://minutemirror.com.pk/security-forces-kill-74-terrorists-in-kp-balochistan-operations-660152/

-     Kachhi and Kharan, Sepoy Hikmatullah: Express Tribune https://tribune.com.pk/story/2638469/soldier-martyred-17-terrorists-killed-in-balochistan-ibos-ispr

-     DG ISPR, 31 Jul 2026: ARY https://arynews.tv/dg-ispr-press-conference-31-july-2026 ; The News https://www.thenews.pk/story/1429409-ispr-dg-briefs-media-on-counterterrorism-efforts-security-situation ; Business Recorder https://www.brecorder.com/news/amp/40432731

-     DG ISPR, 8 Jul 2026: Dawn https://www.dawn.com/news/2013868/dg-ispr-addresses-press-conference ; Geo https://www.geo.tv/latest/672084-ispr-dg-addresses-press-conference-on-security-situation-in-balochistan

-     Mastung camp attack, 12 Nov 2026: Counter-IED Report https://counteriedreport.com/pakistan-bla-claims-18-pakistani-personnel-killed-in-majeed-brigade-attack-in-mastung/ ; Daily Pioneer https://dailypioneer.com/world/explosives-laden-truck-hits-army-camp-in-balochistans-mastung-toll-unconfirmed

-     Mahrang Baloch: Amnesty https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2026/06/pakistan-authorities-must-immediately-release-baloch-activists-handed-life-sentences-following-secret-trial/ ; UN experts https://srdefenders.org/un-experts-condemn-life-sentence-against-baloch-woman-human-rights-defender-in-pakistan-as-grave-injustice-press-release/ ; SHC appeal, Express Tribune https://tribune.com.pk/story/2635727/shc-rejects-state-appeal-challenging-mahrangs-acquittal-in-terrorism-sedition-case

-     Disappearance tallies: New Kerala https://www.newkerala.com/news/a/pakistani-forces-forcibly-disappear-four-men-balochistan-rights-757.htm ; Devdiscourse https://www.devdiscourse.com/article/international/3990341-paank-condemns-disappearances-of-two-baloch-men-in-balochistan ; VBMP 6,000 days, Dawn https://www.dawn.com/news/1955553

-     AJK police and JAAC tolls, July: Express Tribune https://tribune.com.pk/story/2618831/un-rights-chief-calls-for-calm-dialogue-amid-ajk-unrest ; 26 and 7 law enforcement deaths: Dawn https://dawn.com/news/2019216/ajk-police-accuse-jaac-of-targeting-leas-say-26-personnel-martyred-this-year and https://www.dawn.com/news/2019359

-     5 Nov Rawalakot: ThePrint https://theprint.in/world/7-killed-in-pakistan-crackdown-on-pok-protest-protesters-allege-attacks-by-armed-drones/3093118/ ; Daily Pakistan https://en.dailypakistan.com.pk/05-Nov-2026/clashes-reported-in-rawalakot-amid-security-operation-to-end-5-month-kashmir-blockade ; Rangers naik: Minute Mirror https://minutemirror.com.pk/ttap-condemns-violence-against-civilians-in-ajk-658468/

-     12 Nov Rawalakot girls: Kashmir Times https://kashmirtimes.com/news/girl-killed-in-rawalakot-police-protesters-trade-blame ; Radio Pakistan https://www.radio.gov.pk/12-11-2026/two-girls-injured-in-firing-by-outlawed-jaac-members-in-rawalakot

-     Back-channel talks and OPF chairman: Pakistan Observer https://pakobserver.net/opf-clarifies-qamar-razas-role-after-jaac-claims-talks-involved-army-chiefs-representative/

-     The ban and reinstated cases: Dawn https://www.dawn.com/news/amp/2005462 ; Express Tribune https://tribune.com.pk/story/2639465/ttap-calls-for-immediate-end-to-violence-resumption-of-talks-to-quell-ajk-unrest

-     PICSS October 2026: Minute Mirror https://minutemirror.com.pk/pakistan-records-37-drop-in-terrorist-attacks-in-october-654630/ ; CRSS Q3 2026: The Friday Times https://www.thefridaytimes.com/05-Oct-2026/pakistan-violence-83-percent-rise-fatalities-third-quarter